| Record | Athlete | Stat | Year |
| Wins - Season | Mason True
| 51
| 2008
|
| Wins - Career | Lee Shumaker
| 163
| 2004-2008
|
| Consecutive Wins - Season | Mason True
| 47
| 2008
|
| Most Takedowns - Season |
|
|
|
| Most Takedowns - Career |
|
|
|
| Most Pins - Season | John Hill
| 26
| 2019
|
| Brian Brooks | 26 | 1980-1981 |
| Most Pins - Career | John Hill
| 70
| 2019
|
| Fastest Pin | Ryland Ernest | 6 seconds | 2021-22 |
100 Wins - Career
| Ryland Ernest
|
| 2022-23 |
| John Hill |
| 2016-19 |
| Wyatt Lucas |
| 2016-19 |
| Jared Bowman |
| 2012-15 |
| Trevor Bowman |
| 2011-14 |
| Trevor Colman |
| 2009-12 |
| Connor Lewis |
| 2009-12 |
| Connor Smith |
| 2009-12 |
| Anthony Elchert |
| 2007-10 |
| Mason True |
| 2005-08 |
| Lee Shumaker |
| 2005-08 |
| Lyle Riedlinger |
| 2005-08 |
| John Noel |
| 1998-91 |
| 1st Athlete to represent at State | Ted Garrett |
| 1961-1962 |
| 1st Female to be BVC Champion | Charlie Distel |
| 2022-2023 |
| Undefeated Season | Brian Brooks | 43-0 | 1980-1981 |