| School Year | Athlete | Award |
| 2023-2024 | Patrick Ebright, 113 | 1st Team |
| 2022-2023 | Ryland Ernest | 1st Team |
| Patrick Ebright | 2nd Team |
| Keegan Fraley | 2nd Team |
| Levi Crawford | 3rd Team |
| 2021-2022 | Isaac Tolento | 1st Team |
| Brady Conine | 1st Team |
| Adrien Tolento | 2nd Team |
| Logan Crawford | 2nd Team |
| Ryland Ernest | 2nd Team |
| Joe Tardibuono | 3rd Team |
| Levi Crawford | 3rd Team |
| Adrien Tolento | All Academic |
| Isaac Tolento | All Academic |
| 2020-2021 | Chase Distel, 152 | 1st Team |
| Ryland Ernest, 220 | 1st Team |
| Adrien Tolento, 113 | 2nd Team |
| Isaac Tolento, 126 | 2nd Team
|
| Bryan Harrison, 132 | 2nd Team
|
| Kaidn Scott, 160 | 2nd Team
|
| Brady Conine, 170 | 2nd Team
|
| Ethan Smarr, 182 | 2nd Team
|
| 2019-2020 | Isaac Tolento, 113 | 1st Team |
| Bryan Harrison, 126 | 1st Team |
| Chase Distel, 138 | 1st Team |
| Adrien Tolento, 106 | 2nd Team |
| Joe Tardibuono, 170 | 2nd Team |
| Ethan Smarr, 182 | 2nd Team |
| Ryland Ernest, 195 | 2nd Team |
| 2018-2019 | Wyatt Lucas, 126 | 1st Team |
| Jordan McGowen, 138 | 1st Team |
| John Hill, 285 | 1st Team |
| Adrien Tolento, 106 | 2nd Team |
| 2017-2018 | John Hill, 285 | 1st Team |
| Jordan McGowen, 138 | 2nd Team |
| Reese Grine, 145 | 3rd Team |
| Kenneth Durst, 170 | 3rd Team |
| Chase Distel, 126 | 3rd Team |
| 2016-2017 | John Hill, 285 | 1st Team |
| Wyatt Lucas, 120 | 2nd Team |
| Cole Cramer, 152 | 2nd Team |
| Kenneth Durst, | 2nd Team |
| Jordan Marczak, 106 | 3rd Team |
| Jordan McGowen, 126 | 3rd Team |
| Reese Grine, 138 | 3rd Team |
| 2015-2016 | John Hill, 285 | 1st Team |
| Wyatt Lucas, 113 | 2nd Team |
| Jordan McGowen, 120 | 2nd Team |
| Cole Cramer, 160 | 3rd Team |
| 2014-2015 | Jarrod Bowman, 138 | 1st Team |
| Brendan Love, 113 | 2nd Team |
| Evan True, 120 | 2nd Team |
| Cole Cramer, 160 | 2nd Team |
| AJ Knepper, 285 | 2nd Team |
| CJ Grine, 106 | 3rd Team |
| Jarrod Bowman | All Academic |
| 2011-2012 | Jarrod Bowman, | OWL 1st Team |
| Trevor Colman | OWL 1st Team |
| Connor Lewis | OWL 1st Team |
| Connor Smith | OWL 1st Team |
| Tyler Bame | OWL 2nd Team |
| Dominick Diller | OWL 2nd Team |
| 2010-2011 | Trevor Colman | OWL 1st Team |
| Trevor Bowman | OWL 1st Team |
| Connor Lewis | OWL 1st Team |
| Chris Moses | OWL 1st Team |
| Dominick Diller | OWL 2nd Team |
| RJ Sanchez | OWL 2nd Team |
| Connor Smith | OWL 2nd Team |
| 2009-2010 | Connor Lewis | OWL 1st Team |
| Anthony Elchert | OWL 2nd Team |
| Connor Smith | OWL 2nd Team |
| Weston Conley | OWL 2nd Team |
| Tyler Bame | OWL 3rd Team |
| Chris Moses | OWL 3rd Team |
| Trevor Colman | OWL 3rd Team |
| 2008-2009 | Anthony Elchert | OWL 1st Team |
| Connor Lewis | OWL 1st Team |
| Dylan True | OWL 1st Team |
| 2007-2008 | Mason True | OWL 1st Team - MVW |
| Anthony Elchert | OWL 1st Team |
| Lyle Riedinger | OWL 1st Team |
| Lee Shumaker | OWL 1st Team |
| Dylan True | OWL 1st Team |
| 1979-1980 | Fred Noel, 98 | 1st Team |
| John Noel, 105 | 1st Team |
| Joe Kieffer, 119 | 1st Team |
| Weaver, 138 | 1st Team |
| Dane Kirian, 145 | 1st Team |
| Chapman, 175 | 1st Team |
| Jim Blake, HWT | 1st Team |
| E. Noel, 126 | 2nd Team |
| Patten, 155 | 2nd Team |
| Moses | 3rd Team |
| Brian Brooks, 185 | 3rd Team |
| Rader, HWT | 3rd Team |
| 1978-1979 | John Noel | 1st Team |
| Joe Kieffer | 1st Team |
| Dane Kirian | 1st Team |
| Doug Cole | 1st Team |
| Jeff Chapman | 1st Team |
| Jim Blake | 1st team |
| 1977-1978 | Don Kinshaw, 112 | 1st Team |
| Greg Noel, 132 | 1st Team |
| Doug Cole, 155 | 1st Team |
| Don Moses, 167 | 1st Team |
| Roger Weaver | 1st Team |
| Joe Kieffer, 98 | 2nd Team |
| John Kinshaw, 126 | 2nd Team |
| Jeff Chapman, 145 | 2nd Team |
| 1976-1977 | Pat Noel, 98 | 1st Team |
| John Wagner, 132 | 1st Team |
| Steve True, 145 | 1st Team |
| Drew Kirian, 167 | 1st Team |
| John Boes, 175 | 1st Team |
| Dan Hauenstein, 185 | 2nd team |
| 1974-1975 | Pat Noel, 98 | 1st Team - County Champion |
| Dave George, 132 | 1st Team - County Champion
|
| Drew Kirian, 138 | 1st Team - County Champion
|
| John Boes, 155 | 1st Team - County Champion
|
| Don Newlove, 175 | 1st Team - County Champion
|
| Chris Crow, 185 | 1st Team - County Champion
|
| Greg Noel, 105 | 2nd Team |
| Steve True, 126 | 2nd Team |
| Jeff Crow, 145 | 2nd Team |
| Russ Hauenstein, 185 | 2nd Team |
| Jim Nickleson, 112 | 3rd Team |
| John Wagner, 119 | 3rd Team |
| Don Hauenstein, 185 | 3rd Team |
| 1972-1973 | Gary Brubaker, 105 | 1st Team All Area - County Champion |
| Dave George, 112 | County Champion |
| Steve Graham, 119 | 1st Team All Area - County Champion |
| Rick Knepper, HWT | 1st Team All Area - County Champion |
| Jerry Graham, 145 | 2nd Team All Area - County Champion |
| Dan Brooks, 155 | 2nd Team All Area - County Champion |
| John Corbin, 126 | 4th Team All Area |
| Don Frederick, 175 | 4th Team All Area |
| Tom Benner, 132 | 5th Team All Area |
| Jay Flemion Jr, 138 | 5th Team All Area |
| 1969-1970 | Rick Beach | County Champion |