| Member | Sport | Year | Accomplishment | Date Inducted |
| Galen Bruce | Wrestling | 1965 | State Finalist 5th -138 Lbs. | 12/28/2024 |
|
| Kennedy Pratt | Girls' Basketball | 2018-2019 | 1169 Career Basketball Points | 12/28/2024 |
| All-Ohio 2018 & 2019 |
| All-Ohio Academic |
|
| Samantha Watkins | Girls' Track & Field | 2018-2019 | 3rd State Discus 2019 | 12/28/2024 |
| 6th State Discus 2018 |
| School Record Discus 140' 2" |
| 5th State Shot Put 2019 |
| BVC Champion 2019 |
| School Record Shot Put 40' 7.25" |
| 12 Varsity Letter Winner |
|
| Ryan Crow | Football | 2006 | National Football League Coach | 2/17/2024 |
| Tennessee Titans |
| Miami Dolphins |
|
| Gaylan Gallant | Track & Field | 1971 | 1971 6th Place in State 880yd Run | 2/17/2024 |
| 1971 8th Place in State 880yd Relay |
| School Record 880yd Relay 1:33.6 |
|
| Barb Kirian | Track & Field & Volleyball | 1994-1995 | 1995 3rd Place in State 100M Hurdles | 2/17/2024 |
| 1995 4th Place in State 300M Hurdles |
| 1994 5th Place in State 100M Hurdles |
| 1994 BVC Volleyball Co-Player of Year |
| Volleyball School Records in Blocks, Stuff Blocks, & Kills |
|
| Sara May | Girls' Basketball & Volleyball | 1997-1998 | 3rd Team All-Ohio Basketball | 2/17/2024 |
| 1441 Career Basketball Points |
| 1st Team All-BVC & District Volleyball |
| Volleyball School Records in Kills, Blocks, Stuff Blocks, & Digs |
|
| Deryl Nalle | Track & Field | 1971 | 1971 8th Place in State 880yd Relay | 2/17/2024 |
| School Record 880yd Relay 1:33.6 |
| 1971 State Qualifier Long Jump |
| School Record Long Jump 22' 2.25'" |
| 1971 BVC Long Jump Champion |
|
| Maddie Yaple | Track & Field | 2018 | 9th Place State Discus 2018 | 2/17/2024 |
| 2018 BVC Runner Up |
|
| Kelly Abbott | Volleyball Team | 1997 | Season Record 215 | 2/17/2024 |
| Laura Correll | Regional Qualifier |
| Janelle Beck | BVC Runner Up |
| Lori Conine | School Record Season Wins |
| Sara May | 6 Additional Records |
| Jacie Risner |
|
| Allison Smith |
|
| Coach Mylayne Hoover |
|
| Coach Cindy Kloepfer |
|
|
|
| Shae Watkins | Boys’ Basketball | 2015-16 | 1000 Points | 9/2/2022 |
|
| Shae Watkins | Track & Field | 2015-16 | 2016 State Runner Up Discus | 9/2/2022 |
| School Record Discus 186-08 |
| 2016 5th State Shot Put |
| 2015 State Qualifier Shot Put |
| School Record Shot Put 56-02 |
| 4 BVC Championships |
|
| Clint Recker | Track & Field | 2015-16 | 2016 3rd @ State 110m Hurdles | 9/2/2022 |
| 2016 8th @ State 300 Hurdles |
| 2015 7th @ State 110m |
| 2015 State Qualifier 300m |
| School Record 110m hurdles |
| 5 BVC Champions |
|
| Molly Glick | Girls’ Basketball | 2015 | 3rd Team All-Ohio | 9/2/2022 |
| NW Ohio 1st Team |
| District 8 1st Team |
| BVC Player of the Year |
| School’s All-time Leading Scorer |
| 1543 Points |
|
| Regina Fox | Girls’ Basketball | 2012-13 | Season Record 23-4 | 9/2/2022 |
| Miranda Palmer | BVC 8-1 |
| Hannah Ball | BVC Champions |
| Courtney Cramer | Sectional Champions |
| Rebecca Kirian | District Champions |
| Julia Pina | Regional Runner-Up |
| Lizzie Coward |
|
| Abbie Dauterman |
|
| Madison Mock |
|
| Molly Glick |
|
| Coach Randy Baker |
|
| Coach Rod Palmer |
|
| Coach Peter Kern |
|
|
|
| Courtney Cramer | Girls' Basketball | 2014 | District 8 - 1st Team | 1/18/2020 |
| All-Ohio Academic |
| 1000 Career Scorer |
|
| Don Moses |
|
| Decades of Dedication & Service to Arcadia Sports Programs | 1/18/2020 |
|
|
| Miranda Palmer | Girls'Basketball | 2013 | BVC Player of The Year | 1/5/2019 |
| All- Ohio 1st Team |
| All-Ohio Academic |
| 1392 Career Points |
|
| Garrett Schling | Football | 2012 | BVC Defensive Player of The Year | 1/5/2019 |
| All-Ohio 3rd Team, Linebacker |
|
| Kirsten Glick | Softball | 2011-2012 | 2011 All-Ohio 2nd Team | 2/2/2018 |
| 2012 All-BVC Player Of The Year |
|
| Judy Stewart |
|
| Teacher, Coach, & Organized Elementary Fun Day For Over 35 Years | 2/2/2018 |
| Implemented Most Of The Girls Sports |
|
| Heather Cervantes | Volleyball | 1988-1989 | Season Record 21-4 | 12/23/2016 |
| Stephanie Ebersole | BVC Runner-Up |
| Leslie Keckler | District Champions |
| Gina Noriega | 1st District Volleyball Champions |
| Meg Patton |
|
| Karen Ribble |
|
| Rhonda Seel |
|
| Colleen Silverwood |
|
| Amy Walters |
|
| Coach Mylayne Hoover |
|
|
|
| Lee Schumaker | Wrestling | 2008 | Career Record 163 - 18 | 12/28/2013 |
| 4 Time State Qualifier |
|
| Mason True | Wrestling | 2008 | Career Record 158 - 22 | 12/28/2013 |
| 3 Time State Qualifier |
|
| Maddie Aurand | Track and Field | 2003-2006 | 4 Year State Track and Field Qualifier | 2/17/2012 |
| 6th Place in State in 100 Hurdles 2005 |
| All Ohio Academic 2004, 2005, 2006 |
| Century Club All Four Years |
| 708.4 Career Points |
| School Record in 300 Hurdles 45.99 |
| 6 BVC Championships |
|
| A.J. Holman | Boys' Basketball | 2007 | 1000 Career Points | 12/12/2012 |
|
| Tony Good | Boys' Basketball | 1987 | 1000 Points | 2/5/2010 |
|
| Janelle Beck | Girls' Basketball | 1998 | 19-4 Record | 2/5/2010 |
| Lori Conine | 10th in the State |
| Sara May |
|
| Cara Noel |
|
| Tonia Peters |
|
| Allison Smith |
|
| Carrie Suman |
|
| Anna Tardibuono |
|
| Judy Thomas |
|
| Coach Randy Baker |
|
| Coach Mylayne Hoover |
|
|
|
| Joan Conine |
|
| For Her Many Years of Dedicated Service | 2/5/2010 |
| to Arcadia Athletic Students and |
| Arcadia Athletic Boosters |
|
| Chase Beamer | Boys' Basketball | 1992 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Toby Bickel | Boys' Basketball | 1979 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Jerry Blevins | Baseball | 2004 | Drafted by Chicago Cubs - 17th Round | 12/28/2007 |
|
| Rob Colman | Boys' Basketball | 1984 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Mark Chapman | Boys' Basketball | 1996 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Terry Good | Boys' Basketball | 1960 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Duane Margraf | Boys' Basketball | 1980 | 1000 points | 1/12/2007 |
|
| Amy (Walters) Musson | Girls' Basketball | 1986-1989 | All-Ohio Special Mention 1989 | 12/28/2007 |
| 464 Career Assists |
|
| Cara Noel | Girls' Basketball | 1996-1999 | All-Ohio Honorable Mention - 1999 | 12/28/2007 |
| 405 Career Assists |
|
| Gary Bedlion | Wrestling-Coach | 1971-1979 | 7 BVC/County Championships | 12/27/2005 |
| 5 Wrestlers Placed At State |
| 1 State Champion |
|
| Katie Risner | Volleyball | 2004 | Four Year/Three Sports | 12/28/2004 |
| Girls' Basketball | Varsity Letter Winner |
| Softball |
|
|
|
| Luke Ritchey | Baseball | 2002 | All-Ohio 2nd Team -Division IV | 12/28/2004 |
| Outfielder |
|
| Jessica Sheline | Girls' Basketball | 2004 | All-Ohio Academic - Division IV | 12/28/2004 |
| 1,000 Career Points |
| Shannon Conine | Girls' Basketball | 2002 | All-Ohio Academic Division IV | 12/20/2003 |
|
| Erica Sheline | Girls' Basketball | 2002 | All-Ohio Academic - Division IV | 12/20/2003 |
|
| Flora Gonzales | Girls' Basketball | 1983-1984 | Regional Semifinalists | 12/20/2003 |
| Deb Marvin | Record 22-3 |
| Cindy Rader |
|
| Cara Risner |
|
| Christie Risner |
|
| Cindy Schilt |
|
| Maureen Silverwood |
|
| Tammy Tienarend |
|
| Cyndi Tufts |
|
| Cassie Walters |
|
| Cathie Walters |
|
| Karen Weaver |
|
| Coach Randy Baker |
|
| Coach Mylayne Hoover |
|
|
|
| Brad Adams | Boys' Basketball | 1977-1979 Teams | 1977-1978-- 18-5 Record, | 12/20/2003 |
| Trent Beamer | Regional Semifinalist, |
| Toby Bickel | BVC Champs |
| Jon Fleegle |
|
| Bill Graber | 1978-1979-- 20-4 Record, |
| Scott Hedden | Regional Finalists |
| Denny Holman |
|
| Kenny Holman |
|
| Duane Margraf |
|
| Bob Pessell |
|
| Denny Smith |
|
| Rob Smith |
|
| Tim Smith |
|
| Todd Sopher |
|
| Bryan Switzger |
|
| Coach Alan Baker |
|
| Assistant Coach |
|
| Dan Hilty |
|
|
|
| Coach Randy Baker |
|
| Varsity Girls' Basketball Coach. In honor for many years of outstanding service and dedication to the Arcadia Athletic Program since 1983. | 1/27/2001 |
|
|
| Rich Bame | Golf Team | 1996 | Team Record 21-0 | 2/18/2000 |
| David Bliss | BVC Runner-Up |
| Brent Dreisbach |
|
| Craig Hummel |
|
| Ryan Margraf |
|
| Jon Moyer |
|
| Zach Theis |
|
| Josh Williams |
|
| Coach Cassie Ohlrich |
|
|
|
| Sara May | Girls' Basketball | 1997 |
| 2/18/2000 |
|
| Mike Hengsteler | Track & Field | 1990 | 3rd place @ State | 2/13/1998 |
| 300 Meter Intermediate Hurdles 39.13 |
|
| Heather Mengert | Track Field | 1996 | 4th place @ State | 12/23/1997 |
| Shot Put 37 feet 6 inches |
|
| Kenneth Anderson |
|
| Basketball Clock Operator - Over 40 Years of Service to Arcadia Athletes | 2/24/1995 |
|
|
| Barb Kirian | Track Field | 1994-95 | 5th place @ State | 12/22/1995 |
| 100 Meter Hurdles (1994) |
| 3rd place @ State |
| 100 Meter Hurdles (1995) |
| 4th place @ State |
| 300 Meter Hurdles (1995) |
|
| Brett Inbody | Boys 'Basketball | 1985-89 | 1,000 Rebounds | 12/10/1993 |
| 1,000 Points |
|
| Erin Vackert | Football | 1991 | All-Ohio 2nd Team, Linebacker | 12/10/1993 |
| 1992 | All-Ohio 1st Team, Linebacker |
|
|
| Jacob Warrington | Football | 1991 | UPI 2nd Team, Running Back | 12/18/1992 |
|
| Jane Recker | Track & Field | 1989 | 2nd place @ State 1600 Meters | 12/18/1992 |
|
| Jean Recker | Track & Field | 1989 | 2nd place @ State 800 Meters | 12/18/1992 |
|
| Jane Recker | Track & Field | 1989 | 3rd place @ State 3200 Relay | 12/18/1992 |
| Amy Walters |
| Jean Recker |
| Colleen Silverwood |
|
| Jane Recker | Cross Country | 1988 | 2nd place @ State | 12/18/1992 |
|
| Eric Vackert | Baseball | 1989 | All- Ohio 1st Team Pitcher | 12/18/1992 |
|
| Jean Recker | Girls' Basketball | 1989 | FINAL FOUR | 12/18/1992 |
| Jane Recker | STATE TOURNAMENT |
| Amy Walters |
|
| Kathy Knox |
|
| Heather Cervantes |
|
| Colleen Silverwood |
|
| Carol Moyer |
|
| Nicole Kieffer |
|
| Erica Gingrich |
|
| Rachel Seel |
|
| Shauna Bishop |
|
| Lorie Clouse |
|
| Coach Randy Baker |
|
| Assistant Coach |
|
| Mylayne Hoover |
|
|
|
| Dusty Wilson | Wrestling | 1986 | Runner-Up @ State | 9/4/1987 |
| 145 Pound Weight Class |
|
| Christie Risner | Track & Field | 1984 | 2nd place @ State | 9/4/1987 |
| Cathie Walters | 800 Meter Relay 1:46.55 |
| Cara Risner |
|
| Cassie Walters |
|
|
|
| Gerald Binger |
|
| For Distinguished Service and Loyal Dedication to Arcadia Athletes | 2/21/1986 |
|
|
| Gary Bowman | Track & Field | 1974 | 2nd place @ State High Jump | 2/15/1985 |
|
| Cassie Walters | Track & Field | 1981 | 4th place @ State Long Jump | 2/15/1985 |
| 1983 | 1st place @ State High Jump |
| 1984 | 3rd place @ State High Jump |
|
|
| Cassie Walters | Basketball | 1983-84 | All-State UP 2nd Team | 2/15/1985 |
| All-State AP 3rd Team |
|
| Joseph Boes | Football | 1983 | All-Ohio Leading Rusher 1836 Yards | 2/24/1984 |
| Class A, AA, AAA |
|
| Miriam Boes | Track & Field | 1976 | 3rd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| 1978 | 220 Yard Dash 1976: 25.7 |
| 1978: 25.6 |
|
|
| Brian Brooks | Football | 1980 | All-Ohio Defensive End | 2/24/1984 |
|
| Brian Brooks | Wrestling | 1980-81 | STATE CHAMPION | 2/24/1984 |
| 175 Pound Weight Class |
|
| Jeff Crow | Wrestling | 1976 | STATE CHAMPION | 2/24/1984 |
| 155 Pound Weight Class |
|
| Kelly Diebley | Track & Field | 1981 | 3rd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| Long Jump 17'1" (1981) |
| 1982 | STATE CHAMPION |
| High Jump 5'4" (1982) |
|
|
| Jeff Dyer | Track & Field | 1971 | 3rd place @ State Mile Run 4:33 | 2/24/1984 |
|
| Fred Noel | Wrestling | 1981-82 | 2nd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| 98 Pound Weight Class (1981-82) |
| 1982-83 | 4th place @ State |
| 112 Pound Weight Class (1982-83) |
|
|
| Eric Switzer | Football | 1983 | All-Ohio Offense, Guard | 2/24/1984 |
| Associated Press Poll |
|
| Steve True | Wrestling | 1977 | 2nd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| 145 Pound Weight Class |
|
| Roger Weaver | Wrestling | 1978 | 3rd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| Heavyweight |
|
| Kendra Beamer | Track & Field | 1979 | 3rd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| Miriam Boes | 880 Yard Relay 1:47.1 |
| Cathy Dray |
|
| Anna Hitchings |
|
|
|
| Anna Hitchings | Track & Field | 1978 | STATE CHAMPIONS | 2/24/1984 |
| Linda Nau | 880 Yard Medley Relay 1:45.7 |
| Miriam Boes |
|
| Cathy Dray |
|
|
|
| Miriam Boes | Track & Field | 1979 | 3rd place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| Cathy Dray | Mile Relay 4:07.0 |
| Patty Recker |
|
| Anna Hitchings |
|
|
|
| Kendra Beamer | Track & Field | 1980 | 4th place @ State | 2/24/1984 |
| Cathy Dray | 880 Yard Relay 1:47.8 |
| Anna Hitchings |
|
| Leann Holman |
|
|
|
| Miriam Boes | Track & Field | 1978 | STATE CHAMPIONS | 2/24/1984 |
| Kendra Beamer | Mile Relay 4:05.0 |
| Cathy Dray |
|
| Anna Hitchings |
|
|
|