| School Year | Athlete | Award |
| 2023-2024 | Isaac Stoner | 2nd Team |
| Owen Rader | 3rd Team |
| Koen Harris | Honorable Mention |
| Jacoby Ellis | Honorable Mention |
| 2022-2023 | Isaac Stoner | Honorable Mention |
| Owen Rader | Honorable Mention |
| 2021-2022 | Josh Cassell | 3rd Team |
| Hunter Phlipot | Honorable Mention |
| Brycen Lucius | Honorable Mention |
| Aiden Clagg | All-Academic |
| 2020-2021 | Logan Boes | Honorable Mention |
| Evan Cohee | Honorable Mention |
| Joel Lininger | All-Academic |
| 2019-2020 | Hayden Rader | 3rd Team |
| Justen Stoner | Honorable Mention |
| Logan Boes | Honorable Mention |
| Hayden Rader | All-Academic |
| Justen Stoner | All-Academic |
| 2018-2019 | Eli Palmer | Honorable Mention |
| Cole Coppus | Honorable Mention |
| Eli Palmer | All-Academic |
| Luke Metzger | All-Academic |
| 2017-2018 | Levi Squire | Honorable Mention |
| Eli Palmer | Honorable Mention |
| Samuel Stahl | All-Academic |
| 2016-2017 | Alex Pessell | 3rd Team |
| Levi Squire | Honorable Mention |
| Eli Palmer | Honorable Mention |
| Alex Pessell | All-Academic |
| Ethan Boes | All-Academic |
| 2015-2016 | Shae Watkins | 2nd Team |
| Chad Baker | Honorable Mention |
| Clint Recker | Honorable Mention |
| Chad Baker | All-Academic |
| Clint Recker | All-Academic |
| Shae Watkins | All-Academic |
| 2014-2015 | Josh Ireland | 1st Team |
| Shae Watkins | 3rd Team |
| Hayden Ramsey | Honorable Mention |
| Dylan Conine | Honorable Mention |
| Hayden Ramsey | All-Academic |
| Dylan Conine | All-Academic |
| 2013-2014 | Hayden Ramsey | Honorable Mention |
| Shae Watkins | Honorable Mention |
| Sawyer Kieffer | All-Academic |
| 2012-2013 | Casey Mock | 3rd Team |
| Hayden Ramsey | Honorable Mention |
| Shae Watkins | Honorable Mention |
| 2011-2012 | Casey Mock | 3rd Team |
| Grant Baker | Honorable Mention |
| Jimmy Graham | Honorable Mention |
| Johnston Baird | All-Academic |
| Grant Baker | All-Academic |
| Jimmy Graham | All-Academic |
| 2010-2011 | Casey Mock | 3rd Team |
| Grant Baker | Honorable Mention |
| Jimmy Graham | Honorable Mention |
| Brandan Fry | All Academic |
| 2009-2010 | Jordan Duncan | Honorable Mention |
| Julian Pina | Honorable Mention |
| Clay Baker | All-Academic |
| Patrick Coward | All-Academic |
| Jordan Duncan | All-Academic |
| 2008-2009 | Landon Fleegle | Honorable Mention |
| Julian Pina | Honorable Mention |
| 2007-2008 | CJ Holman | 2nd Team |
| Landon Fleegle | Honorable Mention |
| Austin Riggs | Honorable Mention |
| CJ Holman | All-Academic |
| Brett Valentine | All-Academic |
| 2006-2007 | AJ Holman | 1st Team |
| Kirk Ridenour | Honorable Mention |
| Brendan Valentine | Honorable Mention |
| Kirk Ridenour | All-Academic |
| 2005-2006 | AJ Holman | 2nd Team |
| CJ Holman | Honorable Mention |
| Kirk Ridenour | Honorable Mention |
| James Stone | All-Academic |
| 2004-2005 | AJ Holman | Honorable Mention |
| Eric Warren | Honorable Mention |
| 2003-2004 | AJ Holman | Honorable Mention |
| Eric Warren | Honorable Mention |
| 2002-2003 | Brett Smarr | 3rd Team |
| Curtis Frisch | Honorable Mention |
| Eric Warren | Honorable Mention |
| 2001-2002 | Ryan Pessell | 1st Team |
| Grant Saum | Honorable Mention |
| Brett Smarr | Honorable Mention |
| 2000-2001 | Ryan Pessell | 2nd Team |
| Cary Wade | Honorable Mention |
| Nate Abbott | Honorable Mention |
| 1997-1998 | Rob Ellis | 1st Team |
| 1996-1997 | Jeff Noel | 1st Team |
| Rob Ellis | 2nd Team |
| Bret Colman | Honorable Mention |
| Kurt Karhoff | Honorable Mention |
| Jeff Noel | All-Academic |
| Brandon Koehler | All-Academic |
| 1995-1996 | Mark Chapman | 1st Team |
| Jeff Noel | 3rd Team |
| Jeff Adams | Honorable Mention |
| Josh May | Honorable Mention |
| 1994-1995 | Mark Chapman | 2nd Team |
| Matt Fetrow | Honorable Mention |
| Jeff Noel | Honorable Mention |
| 1993-1994 | Mark Chapman | 3rd Team |
| Dan Fetrow | All-Academic |
| Aaron Geckle | All-Academic |
| 1991-1992 | Chase Beamer | 1st Team |
| Curt Cramer | Honorable Mention |
| Toby Brubaker | Honorable Mention |
| 1990-1991 | Shilo Frankart | 1st Team |
| Ron Burnett | 2nd Team |
| Mitch Smith | Honorable Mention |
| Chase Beamer | Honorable Mention |
| Shilo Frankart | All Academic |
| Mitch Smith | All Academic |
| 1989-1990 | Trent Pessell | Honorable Mention |
| Matt Gingrich | Honorable Mention |
| 1988-1989 | Brett Inbody | BVC Player of the Year |
| Trent Pessell | Honorable Mention |
| 1987-1988 | Brett Inbody | 1st Team |
| Kevin Tufts | Honorable Mention |
| Craig Risner | Honorable Mention |
| 1983-1984 | Coach Tom Lee | Coach of the Year |
| 1979-1980 | Dune Margraf | 1st Team |
| Sam Strausbaugh | Honorable Mention |
| 1978-1979 | Toby Bickel | 1st Team |
| Jon Fleegle | 2nd Team |
| Duane Margraf | 2nd Team |
| Trent Beamer | Honorable Mention |
| Denny Holman | Honorable Mention |
| 1977-1978 | Bob Pessell | 1st Team |
| Jon Fleegle | 1st Team |
| Rob Smith | 2nd Team |
| Duane Margraf | Honorable Mention |
| Toby Bickle | Honorable Mention |
| 1976-1977 | John Roller | 2nd Team |
| Rick Good | Honorable Mention |
| 1972-1973 | Jerry Risner | Honorable Mention |
| 1971-1972 | Stan Scarbrough | 1st Team, Forward |
| Ron Conine | Honorable Mention, Guard |
| 1970-1971 | Lee Anderson | 1st Team, Guard |
| Jim Margraf | 2nd Team, Forward |
| Deryl Nalle | Honorable Mention, Forward |
| Ron Conine | Honorable Mention, Guard |
| 1969-1970 | Lee Anderson | All-Conference |
| Jim Margraf | All-Conference |
| Deryl Nalle | All-Conference |
| 1968-1969 | Dave Crouse | 1st Team |
| John Dutton | 2nd Team |
| Ed Bishop | 2nd Team |
| Jon Hill | Honorable Mention |
| Dave Thomas | Honorable Mention |
| 1967-1968 | Al Russell | 1st Team, Forward |
| Gary Conine | 2nd Team, Guard |
| Dave Crouse | Honorable Mention, Forward |
| Ed Bishop | Honorable Mention, Center |
| 1966-1967 | Kerry Gunn | All-County |
| 1964-1965 | Roger Good | All-County, 1st String |
| 1960-1961 | Jack Risner | All-County |
| John Peters | All-County |
| 1957-1958 | Gerald Gaertner | All-County |
| Terry Good | All-County |
| 1955-1956 | John Diebley | 1st Team All-County |
| 1954-1955 | Bill Diebley | All-County |
| John Diebley | Honorable Mention |
| 1939-1940 | Ralph Leonard | 2nd Team All-Tournament Team |
| 1937-1938 |
| Sports commentators from radio stations selected the All-American team |
| Norman Fenstermaker | All-American |
| Robert Bushong | All-American |
| Emmett Huntley | All-American - Captain |
| Howard Huntley | All-American |
| Junior Carpenter | All-American |
| 1932-1933 | Gerald Bame | Honorable Mention |
| Carl Peters | Honorable Mention |
| Paul Fisher | Honorable Mention |
| 1930-1931 | Irvin Fox | All-County |
| George Long | All-County |
| 1928-1929 | Carleton Bricker | All-County 1st Team |
| 1924-1925 | Paul Bricker | All-County, Guard |
| Glenn Pore | All-County, Guard |